Here's the short answer: if you want to know whether an NHL defenseman is actually good at his job, stop looking at points and plus/minus, and start looking at Corsi, Expected Goals, and Zone Starts. Those three metrics—plus PDO, the "puck luck" check—measure what defensemen are paid to do: suppress opponent offense and control play. A defenseman who doesn't score but consistently tilts the ice in his team's favor is a valuable player, and the box score will never tell you that.
Beyond the Box Score: Why Advanced Stats Matter for Defensemen
Traditional hockey statistics were built to credit the people who touch the puck last. Goals, assists, penalty minutes—none of them describe what happens in the other fifty feet of the rink. Plus/minus tries, but it's a blunt instrument: it measures a player's even-strength goal differential, and it's widely treated as less predictive of future performance than the shot-based metrics that analytics popularized.
The gap matters most for defensemen. Sean Shapiro's reporting on how NHL teams use analytics offers a concrete illustration: when the Colorado Avalanche took a chance on Valeri Nichushkin, a player whose lack of goals and penalty minutes made him look disposable to traditional scouting, the team—according to league chatter Shapiro relayed—was looking at underlying numbers about how he suppressed opponent offense, betting that even a minor normalization would make him a low-risk signing. That's the whole thesis in one anecdote. The underlying numbers saw a player the box score didn't.
Analytics itself is no longer fringe. As the general reference on ice hockey analytics notes, these statistics were once the domain of bloggers and amateur statisticians, but NHL teams increasingly adopted them, and the league mainstreamed the vocabulary when it partnered with SAP to launch an enhanced statistical package during the 2014–15 season.
Possession Metrics: Understanding Corsi
Corsi is the foundation, and it's simpler than it sounds. The NHL officially calls it shot attempts (SAT), and it's the sum of shots on goal, missed shots, and blocked shots. A player's Corsi For and Corsi Against are counted while he's on the ice; the differential and the percentage tell you which direction play flows when he's out there.
Northwestern's Sports Analytics Group describes it plainly as a plus/minus statistic for shots on goal for a given player. That's the key insight: it's a possession proxy. You can't shoot if you don't have the puck, and you can't be scored on much if the other team never shoots. A defenseman with a strong Corsi For percentage is tilting the ice, shift after shift, whether or not anyone notices him.
One refinement matters. The hockey analytics reference notes that raw Corsi can be distorted by "score effects"—a leading team tends to sit back and let the trailing team rack up shot attempts—so analysts moved from "Corsi close" filters toward score-adjusted weighting, where each shot is weighted by the game state. When you see a score-adjusted Corsi number, that's what it's doing.





