Scoring average tells you who won. It tells you almost nothing about how. Two players can post identical 68s while playing completely different games—one bombing it offline and scrambling, another plotting fairways and hitting wedges close. If you want to evaluate a PGA Tour player's actual strengths and weaknesses, you need four metrics working together: Strokes Gained: Total, Strokes Gained: Off-the-Tee and Approach, Driving Distance, and Driving Accuracy. Here's how each is calculated, what it reveals, and how to combine them.
Beyond the Scorecard: Understanding Advanced Golf Metrics
Why isn't a scoring average enough? Because traditional stats count outcomes without weighing them. That's the core problem, and golf instruction writers at WhyGolf explain it plainly: fairways hit and putts per round treat a 300-yard drive that finishes in the first cut the same as one that finishes in the trees. Twenty-eight putts in a round looks great—until you realize the player missed every green and chipped it close.
Traditional stats also borrow credit across categories. A great short game can mask poor approach play. Poor putting can hide brilliant ball-striking. You end up unable to say where strokes were actually gained or lost.
Advanced metrics fix this by measuring every shot against a benchmark. The result is a set of numbers in a single, common unit—strokes—that lets you compare a player's driving against their putting, and against the rest of the tour. That's the shift: from counting results to weighing them.
One scope note before we go deeper. Everything here applies to the PGA Tour and other elite professional men's tours. The baselines are tour-specific, and as we'll see, a number from one baseline can never be compared against a number from another.
Strokes Gained: The Gold Standard of Performance Measurement
Strokes Gained scores a shot instead of counting it. The conceptual formula, as WhyGolf breaks it down: expected strokes from where the ball started, minus expected strokes from where it finished, minus the one stroke you used. If that number is positive, you beat the benchmark. If it's negative, you lost ground.
Where do those "expected strokes" come from? A research paper on putting statistics from Simon Fraser University notes the methodology was initially developed by Mark Broadie in 2008 and extended by Fearing, Acimovic and Graves in 2011, and that the calculation has been made possible by ShotLink data, which records information on every shot taken on the PGA Tour. ShotLink lasers measure the start and finish of essentially every shot in tournament play, producing a sample large enough to say with confidence what an average tour player scores from 150 yards in the fairway, from a greenside bunker, or from twenty feet on the green.
Here's a worked example from the Columbia Business School analysis of golfer performance. Suppose the tour field averages 3.2 strokes on a long par-3. A player's tee shot finishes on the green, leaving a 16-foot putt, from which the tour field averages 1.8 putts. The player has moved from a 3.2-stroke position to a 1.8-stroke position using one stroke—so the tee shot gained 0.4 strokes against the field. Every shot gets this treatment.
Because the units are the same for all shot types, Strokes Gained offers a consistent method for evaluating different aspects of the game—it solves the problem of incommensurable measures in standard golf statistics, as the Columbia paper puts it, citing Larkey and Smith.
The real power comes from grouping shots into four categories, as the golf analytics site Golfity explains: Off-the-Tee (driving on par 4s and 5s, accounting for both distance and accuracy), Approach (shots toward the green from 100+ yards), Around-the-Green, and Putting. Per Golfity's account of Broadie's research, approach shots explain the largest portion of scoring differences between players. The four categories sum to Strokes Gained: Total.





